Some of the companies and individuals involved in this trade
have a history of criminality. Johannes Onderwater a Dutch national was convicted
5 or so years ago by Dover magistrate’s court
of secretly transporting live sheep
through the port of Dover whilst describing the shipment as frozen meat. In the
1980s Thomas Lomas, a UK national, was gaoled for committing a lucrative criminal
fraud involving the transportation of
farm animals. In early 2014 Lomas and his company, Channel Exports Ltd
were convicted by Dover magistrate’s court of breaches of animal welfare
regulations which resulted in the destruction of 47 sheep at the Port of
Ramsgate in September 2013. Lomas and his company were fined £10,000 and Lomas
was handed down a 6 month suspended gaol sentence.
On the back of the death of the 47 sheep Thanet Council rightly
suspended further live exports. After 6 weeks this suspension was overturned by
the High Court. Today’s announcement sets the compensation for the 6 weeks of lost
trade and the inconvenience caused at
£2.3 million plus an award of court costs to the exporters of approximately
£300,000. So Thanet Council taxpayers will now have to find £2.6 million which is
more than 10% of its annual budget! I
have asked for a copy of the High Judgment which hopefully the Council will let
me have and I may then be able to provide further details of why the High Court
made this extraordinary decision.
One thing which concerns me is that it would have been
virtually impossible for the exporters to have lost £2.3million during the six
week period in which their activities were suspended. Until the suspension the
exporters were only carrying out 2 shipments per week. They must have been transporting very expensive sheep to justify
this level of compensation, or perhaps there was another cargo we know nothing
about? Hopefully the High Court papers will reveal the truth.
Either way I think the Dutch and UK tax
authorities should be alerted to this
court case as it may reveal interesting information about the financial affairs
of Onderwater and Lomas.
But what makes me furious is the perverse situation whereby
convicted animal welfare abusers are massively compensated for having their cruel
and barbaric trade suspended as a consequence of their own neglectful and cruel
actions . In my
opinion, this is nothing less than the payment of Blood Money to animal abusers. It’s a travesty of justice which
makes me so fucking angry. Having said
that this ridiculous and totally unfair situation makes me more determined than
ever before to fight through peaceful direct action and politically through the
UK parliament and the EU to stop this evil and cruel trade once and for all. I
hope that you will join me in this campaign.
Well said and Clive and Bob and Iris have proved to be very expensive for us all
ReplyDeleteThank you for your compassion, determination and guts Ian. The judgement is obviously flawed. Onderswater and Lomas are beyond evil for the cruelty they inflict on British sheep. The barbaric cruelty continues during long transport to slaughter. We should be responsible for our farm animals welfare through out their lives. ON THE HOOK NOT THE HOOF. Live exports aren't necessary.
ReplyDeleteDid the council not seek legal advice before they imposed the bans? if not then the chief exec and her team at the time were negligent. if so then they should ask for heir legal fees back.
ReplyDelete