Former Thanet Councillor Ian Driver has called on Kent
County Council (KCC) to abandon its plans to build Thanet Parkway station,
following revelations that anticipated construction costs have soared. The Thanet Parkway Business Case,
published in March 2014, estimated building costs at £11.2 million (1). But documents
uncovered by Driver which were discussed by the Kent & Medway Economic
Partnership (KMEP) in August (2) show that estimated costs have now risen by a massive 83% to almost £21
million (2) in just over 2 years.
In 2014 the Government agreed to pay £10 million of the
estimated £11million cost of building the station through its Local Growth Fund, leaving KCC and Thanet Council to
cover the predicted £1million funding gap. With building costs now estimated at
£20.5 million, KCC and Thanet Council would need to find £9.3 million to plug
the funding gap - a highly unlikely prospect given the huge budget reductions
which have been forced upon the two councils. In June 2016 a KCC spokesperson downplayed Driver’s warnings about escalating Parkway building costs, saying that the “current cost estimate for construction is £16 million” (3). The latest documents reveal that Driver was right all along. The proposed station will require new control mechanisms and improvements will have to be made to the Cliffsend level crossing, bringing the total costs to astronomic £20.5 million (4).
Driver has condemned Thanet’s politicians for failing to alert local people to the dramatic cost escalation. He said “This is one of KCC’s most important and prestigious transport projects. Information on the growing construction costs for the station has been available since January, yet not a single one of Thanet’s 8 KCC councillors has made a public statement about it. They are clearly not doing their job and failing to keep residents informed”.
He added “Thanet Council’s Joint Transportation Board is supposed to consider public transport work programmes such as Parkway station and be a forum for consultation between KCC and TDC on policies, plans and strategies for public transport – yet the Board and its 14 elected councillor members has also failed to discuss Thanet Parkway station at any of its meetings during the past year. This lack of debate about an important Thanet transport issue is shameful. I wonder what these councillors, who have special responsibility for transport in Thanet, have be doing whilst the construction costs of the Parkway station have been skyrocketing?”
“Given that all 3 parties (UKIP, Tory & Labour) and senior KCC and TDC officers are all committed to supporting Parkway station, my suspicion is that debate on the controversial station and its rapidly growing construction costs is being deliberately and undemocratically stifled because the powers that be are afraid of the resulting public outcry, which might put an end to their plans. In fact an overwhelming majority of the comments submitted by local people about Parkway station during the 2014 public consultation exercise, were opposed to the construction of the station. No wonders senior officers and politicians want to keep this quite!”
“I’ve always argued that Thanet Parkway Station is a
massive white elephant which is not needed. It will actually increase journey
times from existing Thanet stations to Canterbury, Ashford and London, and it
could ultimately lead to the closure of some of Thanet’s town stations. Building
the station will also cause substantial environmental damage. A huge area of
farmland will be concreted over to accommodate the platforms, a 350 space car
park and approach roads. Extra traffic to and from the station will cause
congestion and air pollution in an area which is already very congested. If the
station gets planning permission, property developers will be queuing up to
submit planning applications to build
houses on all the open farmland around
the site, and if this happens, Cliffsend village will quickly be swallowed up by Ramsgate”.
“I have talked to many local people about Thanet Parkway
station, and most believe that it would be better to spend money providing more
parking spaces near Ramsgate station, especially on the site of the old
swimming pool, and improving public
transport links to it. If TDC and KCC plan to continue with this hare-brained
scheme, they will be wasting £21 million of taxpayers’ money on a huge
polluting white elephant that isn’t needed and that nobody wants”.
1. See http://www.kent.gov.uk/roads-and-travel/travelling-around-kent/thanet-parkway-railway-station and then click on Draft Business Case Report.
2014 estimated construction price is on page 1.
2. Click
on Related Documents link here http://kmep.org.uk/documents/KMEP_Board_Papers_-_1_August_16.pdf
and see item 9 page 44.
3. See
Kent Online Kent County Council insists Thanet Parkway station won’t be derailed
despite rising costs http://www.kentonline.co.uk/thanet/news/estimated-costs-of-thanet-parkway-97489/
4. See
note 2 above.
The Parkway station will benefit 2 people Musgrove and Cartner of Discovery Park and Stone Hill Park... Interesting that as Discovery Park in theory owes Kent County Council money and that KCC likes to pour money into Discovery Park and calls it a success.
ReplyDeleteInterested to know why you think Discovery Park owes KCC money. Can you tell me how much and when the loans were granted?
DeleteThe government when Eric Pickles was a minister in 2014 gave Discovery Park £6 millions (as and enterprise zone) to refurbish some of the buildings but nothing to do with KCC and not repayable
https://democracy.kent.gov.uk/documents/s49905/Item%20B1%20-%20Record%20of%20Decision%20Discovery%20Park%20Enterprise%20Zone%20Growing%20Places%20Fund.pdf
DeleteStill not KCC money but central governments money allocated by local authorities. The Growing Places Fund is supporting key infrastructure projects designed to unlock wider economic growth, create jobs and build houses in England.
Deletewhy would building houses at Discovery Park be of use?
Deletehow many civil servants are being paid to not build the Parkway?
DeleteWell said Ian: a foolish project with he end of Manston - we ant the old swimming pool rebuilt!
ReplyDeleteThe replacement of the swimming pool in the Warre Recreation ground would certainly be an asset, provided the council did a proper job of getting it out to tender, before some bright spark decides to build "affordable" homes on it. Parkway is a dead end, forget it before we end up in even more debt.
ReplyDelete